Stile Antico, Lake District Summer Music, Kendal Parish Church

Stile Antico, an ensemble of young British singers, made a welcome return to Kendal Parish Church in a programme of music by the great 16th Century composer William Byrd and the contemporary James MacMillan. As one might expect from a prizewinning group with an international reputation the singers’ performance was first-rate: impeccable tuning, balance, ensemble and intonation were just some of the many obvious signs of excellence displayed throughout the evening. The idea of building a programme around the liturgical works of two Catholic composers separated by over three centuries was an interesting one; and it worked beautifully! As the excellent programme notes pointed out, in the work of both composers there is ‘a sensitivity to musical tradition and its historical role in liturgical music.’ Although, of course, each composer communicates in his own way, using the musical techniques and language of his own time, both share a common staring point - plainchant. Byrd’s music may not always quote directly from plainchant but his melodic lines are infused with it: MacMillan’s music often intertwines plainchant with the Scottish folk elements.

In the programme, it was fascinating to hear how the two composers interpreted the same text, and to observe similarities and differences in their approach. It was also a delight to hear live performances of some of the more virtuosic works of the two composers, some beyond the reach of most amateur choirs. For example, MacMillan’s Communion motet for the Feast of Pentecost, Factus est repente, with its melismatic soaring soprano lines and ‘Celtic’ inspired ornaments was thrilling in performance.

This was vocal ensemble singing at its very best and an inspiration for all.

Clive Walkley