CONCERNED neighbours failed to block plans for new housing at Kendal's former NHS offices and nurses' home on Brigsteer Road.

Four residents from nearby Lynngarth Drive shared their fears about loss of privacy and increased rainwater run-off with South Lakeland District Council's planning committee.

"When I stand outside my house and look towards the proposed development I am filled with despair," said Clive Carroll, who has lived at Lynngarth Drive for 28 years.

"The peace and tranquillity of Lynngarth Drive will be destroyed forever and that's something I find particularly upsetting."

Russell Armer Ltd and NHS Property Services Ltd plan to convert the late 19th century, Arts and Crafts-style former nurses' home at Tenterfield into seven apartments and three houses; to demolish 'unsightly' modern offices at the back; and build eight new dwellings in the grounds.

Lynngarth Drive resident Michael Johnson said he was concerned about loss of privacy, and neighbour Emma Saner-Haigh predicted that the "semi-rural feel" of Lynngarth Drive would change significantly. During heavy rain, water poured down her driveway and into gardens, and she feared the development would 'exacerbate' this.

Residents had particular concerns about the height of four of the new houses. Andrew Tait, representing developers Russell Armer, told the meeting that those properties were up to 28 metres away from homes on Lynngarth Drive, and that exceeded planning guidelines.

Cumbria County Council's flood relief team was happy with the drainage proposals following further investigation, he added. "The most important thing is it will bring a key building in the Conservation Area back into positive use and prevent future deterioration."

Councillors heard that 'abnormal costs' for demolition and asbestos removal meant the development would not viable with more than two affordable flats.

Cllr John Holmes said he had "no hesitation" in recommending approval, and Cllr Janette Jenkinson said the best had been made of the site. But Cllr David Fletcher said: "It's a case of trying to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear", and Cllr Philip Dixon said: "It always upsets me when I find all the people who live around the site say we feel this is going to be have a detrimental impact on our lives."

The committee voted in favour of approving the plans, subject to details being agreed with the applicants.