Eden MP's Afghanistan documentary airs tonight on TV (From The Westmorland Gazette)
When news happens, text KENEWS and your photos and videos to 80360. Or contact us by email or phone.
Eden MP's Afghanistan documentary airs tonight on TV
1:13pm Monday 28th May 2012 in News
Sited at a crossroads between the Middle East, Central Asia and the Indian subcontinent, Afghanistan has been fought over, occupied and exploited for centuries, not least by opposing superpowers in the west and east.
Penrith and the Border MP, Rory Stewart, has spent years getting to know the country's people and its politics – he even spent two years walking across Pakistan, Iran, Afghanistan, India and Nepal, on a 6,000 mile journey.
Tonight, in the first of a two-part documentary, Mr Stewart will present The Great Game – a Personal View, looking at the tangled history of the country from the first British invasion in 1838.
His journey of discovery was the culmination of over seven years of research and work, and is based on hundreds of interviews. He said it marks the end of the chapter of his life before becoming a Cumbrian MP.
He met with historians and academics from around the world, Afghan royalty, veterans and former CIA chiefs in the USA.
“What is interesting for me is the parallels we have with the 19th century,” he said. “The ways in which empires and superpowers repeatedly get themselves stuck in Afghanistan.
“Quite quickly the conflicts cease to be about Afghanistan and become about ourselves, our pride and our reluctance to admit something has failed, with a sense of inertia.”
A former student of politics, philosophy and economics at Oxford University and officer in the Army, Mr Stewart joined the British Diplomatic Service and served in the British Embassy in Indonesia and, in the wake of the Kosovo campaign, as the British representative in Montenegro.
In 2003, he became coalition Deputy Governor of two provinces in the Marsh Arab region of Southern Iraq and from 2006 to 2008, he lived in Kabul.
There he was the founder and Chief Executive of Turquoise Mountain, a non-profit, non-governmental organisation investing in the development of Afghanistan’s traditional crafts and the rehabilitation of the commercial heart of the old city of Kabul.
Speaking about his experiences in filming the documentary, Mr Stewart said: “The Afghans that I met were often straight forward and just wanted to talk about their personal stories. I heard things from friends that they had never spoken about before, about their part in the wars. One said when he was fighting the Russians he was so hungry and cold and depressed, he felt like walking into a minefield and killing himself.
“Looking at the troubled history of Afghanistan was a reminder of the continual tragedy of the country and how there are just no easy solutions.
“It was very easy for Britain in the 19th century to convince itself it needed to occupy Afghanistan to protect itself, and the same for Russia from the USA and Pakistan. We did the same thing in protecting ourselves from Al-Quaeda.
“When you bring in lots of foreign troops and money, it distorts things in unintended ways. Money brings corruption, troops unfortunately bring violence, and the very presence of a foreign government undermines the Afghan government.”
Mr Stewart said looking at 200 years of the region's history throws up lessons for today's politicians.
“We need to plan better, learn to admit mistakes, and admit sometimes we can't understand something,” he said. “When soldiers have died, nobody wants to feel that it has been in vain. But you don't honour a soldier's death by continuing a war.”
The Great Game – a Personal View airs tonight on BBC2 at 9pm.
Comments(18)
Ben Berry
says...
8:15am Tue 29 May 12
Im looking forward to the next.
laker1
says...
8:52am Tue 29 May 12
Utter wrote:Don't see why - here we have a, still fairly young chap, who has done so much and experienced so much prior to becoming an MP. He is not a 'career' politician who has never lifted a finger before going to Westminster to tell us all how to live our lives. And we all know at least one of those! Rory Stewart has done and achieved a lot for people in Afghamistan and since becoming an MP has done a lot for us Cumbrians. Let's not foget that it was he who helped to instigate the rural broadband incentives which the County Council have pursued, NOT Tim Farron who again has tried to claim the credit for the work of others
I'm looking forward to MANY angry posts from blogtrotter et al about this story and publicity of MPs.....
fellsman
says...
9:05am Tue 29 May 12
laker1 wrote:Can't think who you mean - possibly one of those who tried to become an MP whilst at University and never had a proper job whilst pursuing that aim and now thinks he knows it all
Utter wrote:Don't see why - here we have a, still fairly young chap, who has done so much and experienced so much prior to becoming an MP. He is not a 'career' politician who has never lifted a finger before going to Westminster to tell us all how to live our lives. And we all know at least one of those! Rory Stewart has done and achieved a lot for people in Afghamistan and since becoming an MP has done a lot for us Cumbrians. Let's not foget that it was he who helped to instigate the rural broadband incentives which the County Council have pursued, NOT Tim Farron who again has tried to claim the credit for the work of others
I'm looking forward to MANY angry posts from blogtrotter et al about this story and publicity of MPs.....
Utter
says...
10:11am Tue 29 May 12
Spotty Fish
says...
2:05pm Tue 29 May 12
Utter
says...
3:50pm Tue 29 May 12
Spotty Fish wrote:Come on...you can honestly think the government would let an MP go around what is a war zone without any body guards or soldiers with him?
Having read both The Places In Between, about his walk across Afghanistan, and also The Prince Of The Marshes, about his time in Iraq, I should very much doubt that Mr. Stewart would need the protection of the army. His knowledge, and I would imagine, respect earned, will be second to none in Afghanistan. Irrespective of his politics and what he does now, his past is very interesting and worth reading about. A much more interesting character than 99% of our MP's.
Who has paid for that .... us?
Also who was doing his job in Westminster while he was in Asia? No-one....Penrith had no voice while he was making his programme
Also did he get paid?
Spotty Fish
says...
4:39pm Tue 29 May 12
As for who paid for the trip. Well if it was us via the BBC, I personally think it was a relatively small amount of money well spent to produce such an interesting, informative programme that highlights the futility of the billions of pounds of our money that are currently being spent on a country that has never been successfully occupied.
As for who was looking after poor old Penrith! Come on, surely our MP's can't be expected to sit by the phone waiting to sort out every little problem that arises.
fellsman
says...
5:04pm Tue 29 May 12
Utter wrote:Gosh - has Rory hit a nerve or what - here is an MP who has probably got far more knowledge of the situation in Afghanistan than just about anyone in the country. He has done far more for the people of that country than many others. He uses that mine of knowledge in his job as an MP - lets face it - if most of the MP's who sent us to war in the first place had had that knowledge, we might not be in the mess there that we are out there. Most of our MP's fresh out of college and never having done anything with their lives have been quite happy to send our young soldiers into danger with far less understanding of the situation in that country. What Rory has done in Afghanistan is far more useful to this country than a lot of the jollies that most MP's undertake to far more exotic and less dangerous places for little or no actual benefit to this country, oh yes and that definitely is out of the public purse and they would probably be far better staying in Westminster and representing their constituents. Get off his back and give him the credit he deserves
Spotty Fish wrote:Come on...you can honestly think the government would let an MP go around what is a war zone without any body guards or soldiers with him?
Having read both The Places In Between, about his walk across Afghanistan, and also The Prince Of The Marshes, about his time in Iraq, I should very much doubt that Mr. Stewart would need the protection of the army. His knowledge, and I would imagine, respect earned, will be second to none in Afghanistan. Irrespective of his politics and what he does now, his past is very interesting and worth reading about. A much more interesting character than 99% of our MP's.
Who has paid for that .... us?
Also who was doing his job in Westminster while he was in Asia? No-one....Penrith had no voice while he was making his programme
Also did he get paid?
Utter
says...
5:27pm Tue 29 May 12
fellsman
says...
5:40pm Tue 29 May 12
laker1
says...
5:52pm Tue 29 May 12
Utter
says...
7:10pm Tue 29 May 12
fellsman wrote:That's a silly argument. I have an issue that an MP goes on a foreign jaunt that doesn't help their constituents, on the taxpayer and leaves his constituents without an MP in Westminster.
Great idea - let's ban all MP's from leaving the country - what William Hague was doing in Russia this week was disgraceful, he is not looking after his constituents and he could hold his discussions with the Russian government from the Newsnight studio. It would obviously save us a fortune and would do away with the need for leaks to the media, though the Leveson enquiry might not be too thrilled
@laker1 - Again I don't agree. I don't know what Rory has done to be honest. But that is a discussion we can have.
I am surprised that no-one is having a go at Rory for this! I guess tories being nice to a tory! I shouldn't be suprised!
emmielou
says...
9:07pm Tue 29 May 12
emmielou
says...
9:11pm Tue 29 May 12
JBean2
says...
10:41pm Tue 29 May 12
This is the guy who described his Cumbrian constituents last summer as "pretty primitive people, holding up their trousers with bits of twine and that sort of thing". Glad I'm not one of them!
I'm sure he is a very interesting man to talk to and I'm sure he isn't stupid. He's sitting pretty in a safe Tory seat when reportedly he only knowingly voted Conservative in 2010.
Spotty Fish
says...
10:37am Wed 30 May 12
As for "tories being nice to Tories." Utter tosh, it's just that the man is interesting and has achieved more so far in his life than most of us armchair experts and grumblers achieve in a lifetime.
redhairedgranny
says...
7:49pm Wed 30 May 12
Utter says...
3:09pm Mon 28 May 12