Is wishing on a tree just a waste of cash?

The Westmorland Gazette: A tree stump studded with coins near Ingleton A tree stump studded with coins near Ingleton

A ‘CULTURAL phenomenon’ spreading across the Lake District and Yorkshire Dales has begun to prompt walkers to question the craze.

Coins are being hammered into tree stumps on popular countryside paths such as at High Force at Ingleton – on the popular waterfall walk – paths near to Rydal Cave and at Tarn Hows near Coniston.

The idea is similar to trying to get a wish to come true by throwing coins into fountains and down wishing wells.

Keen walker Tony Carroll has suggested the money would be put to better use helping charities and moun-tain rescue teams.

“Surely there are better ways to dispose of loose change,” said Mr Carroll. “Perhaps the ‘wish’ might better be directed if the money was put in a charity collection box or wishing well – at least the small change would have a better chance of being re-cycled.

“Organisations such as Mountain Rescue and Air Ambulance could arrange to ‘harvest’ the money and put it to good use.

“It seems bizarre in this time of cash-flow problems that people are prepared to hammer their hard-earned cash in to old tree trunks.”

But Nick Owen, leader at Langdale and Ambleside Mountain Rescue, said that although he liked the idea, he questioned the ethics of collecting money from such tree trunks.

“I don’t think it would be in keeping with the spirit with which the money was put there,” he said.

“The coins were not put in these trees with raising money for charity in mind so I am not sure about the legal or ethical ramifications about taking it.”

He added that if a tree stump was established with the specific purpose of helping charity it would be a ‘novel’ way of raising cash for much-needed causes.

A spokesperson for the National Trust said: “It is an interesting cultural phenomenon. It can, of course, have a damaging effect on a living tree, so we’d generally disco-urage people from hammering bits of metal into these.

“Once the coins are hammered into the tree it would be extremely difficult to retrieve them, but usually people are frugal and use small change and coppers to make their wish, which is what people have been doing for centuries with wishing wells.”

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

6:55pm Wed 26 Sep 12

Milkbutnosugarplease says...

You can see this too on a fallen branch on the coffin route from Rydal to Grasmere - near the Rydal end. The coins are 1p, 2p, 5p and a few 10p, so the value of them is pretty small and the effort of pulling them out not worth it for any charity. I think it's a way of getting rid of loose change and, since the wood needs to be partially rotten to take the coins, it won't harm a healthy tree. As to good luck from doing this - who can tell? The Wishing Gate above Grasmere used to be the place for that, but it seems to have been forgotten. It's still there but maybe the farmer wants nobody climbing up it.
You can see this too on a fallen branch on the coffin route from Rydal to Grasmere - near the Rydal end. The coins are 1p, 2p, 5p and a few 10p, so the value of them is pretty small and the effort of pulling them out not worth it for any charity. I think it's a way of getting rid of loose change and, since the wood needs to be partially rotten to take the coins, it won't harm a healthy tree. As to good luck from doing this - who can tell? The Wishing Gate above Grasmere used to be the place for that, but it seems to have been forgotten. It's still there but maybe the farmer wants nobody climbing up it. Milkbutnosugarplease

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree