David Cameron: Urgent improvements needed at Morecambe Bay’s health trust

QUESTION TIME: The Prime Minister in the Commons QUESTION TIME: The Prime Minister in the Commons

THE Prime Minister has said the death of a North Lancashire cancer patient highlights the need for urgent improvements at Morecambe Bay’s three hospitals.

David Cameron told MPs at Prime Minister’s Questions today that patients at the University Hospitals of Morecame Bay Trust (UHMBT) had a ‘right to expect far better standards of care’.

He spoke out after Morecambe and Lunesdale MP David Morris raised the case of grandmother Penny Hegarty, of Over Kellet, who died after recurring breast cancer was allegedly misdiagnosed by a trust doctor.

Mr Morris asked Mr Cameron for an assurance that the troubled trust would be turned around.

Mr Cameron, who sent personal condolences to the Hegarty family, said he was aware of failings at UHMBT.

“It is being turned around,” he said. “That work needs to be undertaken with all speed.”

North Lancashire teaching expert Mrs Hegarty, 62, died after recurring breast cancer was allegedly misdiagnosed as oesteoperosis.

Her husband Phil, 67, has campaigned for an investigation into information management at UHMBT.

“Penny might still be with us if there were better systems in place,” he said. “She didn’t get a good deal. In my view the clinician had done his best. I tried to persuade the trust to look at what went wrong from a management and systems perspective but it refused to respond.”

Related links

The Prime Minister’s comments come in the wake of the resignation of UHMBT chief executive Tony Halsall – a move which has been praised by patients, politicians and clinicians.

Mr Halsall, who had previously refused to resign, stepped down last Friday after health regulators found serious faults with the organisation.

The trust is also facing High Court legal action over the deaths of an Ulverston mother and baby. Carl Hendrickson is suing the trust for negligence after the death of wife Nittaya and baby Chester at Furness General Hospital in 2008.

This and other deaths at the unit sparked coroner’s criticisms and a police investigation which is ongoing.

Monitor and the Care Quality Commission have both launched probes into maternity services, accident and emergency cover, trust management and leadership. However, both declined to comment about Mr Halsall’s resignation Mr Halsall’s decision came just two weeks after Sir David Henshaw was parachuted in as new UHMBT chairman.

Mr Morris and fellow MPs Tim Farron and John Woodcock all welcomed his resignation.

Mr Farron said: “I think Sir David is being open minded where services should go across Morecambe Bay. This is a wonderful opportunity for the trust to expand what it does, bringing services back from Lancaster, to both Westmorland General and Furness General hospitals, including more surgery.”

Comments(8)

Chris Custodiet says...
7:49pm Fri 2 Mar 12

So let's get down to the nitty gritty. Was Tony Halsall one of the real movers and shakers in the NHS in the North West or just a fall guy who would front up wrongful conduct and end up carrying the can? Think about it - seriously.

Chris Custodiet says...
9:30am Sat 3 Mar 12

Page 15 of UHMBT's Annual Report begins as follows:
'The RLI had a very special visitor on 21 August 2008, when the Under Secretary of State for Health Services, Ann Keen, took a tour of the hospital'. This was the same Ann Keen dubbed 'Mrs Expenses' for the roles she and her now late husband played in the MPs expenses scandal. However it was at exactly the same time that Mrs Keen was actively engaged in whitewashing complaints about Bingley Consulting Ltd that three years later resulted in the PCT Chair losing his position.

Chris Custodiet says...
10:02am Sat 3 Mar 12

I appear to have inadvertently omitted that this was the 2008/09 Annual Report. Whilst UHMBT has been financed by PCTs it seems to have been coy about how much comes from each one. The North Lancs PCT is probably the biggest funder of UHMBT.

Chris Custodiet says...
9:50am Sun 4 Mar 12

Correction. UHMBT were coy until 1 October 2010. Published figures for the six months from that date to 31 March 2011 show that UHMBT received £64million from Cumbria PCT and £44milion from North Lancashire PCT.
The report also shows that 'There were no cases of fraud, fruitless payments, clinical negligence, personal injury or compensation where the net payment exceeded £250,000'. Is that reassuring?

Chris Custodiet says...
9:51am Sun 4 Mar 12

Correction. UHMBT were coy until 1 October 2010. Published figures for the six months from that date to 31 March 2011 show that UHMBT received £64million from Cumbria PCT and £44milion from North Lancashire PCT.
The report also shows that 'There were no cases of fraud, fruitless payments, clinical negligence, personal injury or compensation where the net payment exceeded £250,000'. Is that reassuring?

chrismc says...
7:49pm Sun 4 Mar 12

Pity the patients!

WilliamT says...
9:15pm Sun 4 Mar 12

Yes, the nominated Lead Commissioner for UHMB is North Lancs. PCT, but its major commissioner is Cumbria. North Lancs. is largely just a shell now, as Bingley's former pals have mostly been rewarded for failure by moving to the PCT cluster NHS Lancashire. Cumbria has not been affected by 'clustering' as it is its own cluster- this is probably because they needed an isolated body in which to bury the slush fund which will be necessary for UHMB and to pay Northumberland trust for taking over North Cumbria hospitals.
This is an example of the principle that if you're going to have a deficit, it's best to make it a really big one so that the DoH just pays it off on the quiet. This is hardly fair on the areas where they have been making savings, but who says the NHS is fair?

Chris Custodiet says...
7:23am Mon 5 Mar 12

Accompanying Mrs Expenses on her 2008 trip up North was David Morris's predecessor, Geraldine Smith former MP for Morecambe and Lunesdale and member of the Parliamentary Health Select Committee. She deserved credit for her defence of the Morecambe Bay Chinese Cockle Pickers and seemed to be otherwise well-regarded and independently-minded
. So what (or who) persuaded her to join the Royal Society of Blind Eye Practitioners?

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree