Comment: I fear for the future of Ulverston if Sainsbury's opens

First published in Opinion

Totnes fought and won. Southwold fought and lost. In Ulverston there was barely a scuffle.

And so Costa is coming, to a prime town centre site, where it will be in direct competition with the existing and independent coffee shops.

What is the point of this? It’s hard to see how anyone could actually want Costa.

They do, with coffee and cakes, more or less what the independents do but in a more expensive and less interesting way. And you have to queue.

But the timid and faint-hearted will go there, and things will be harder for local businesses, and Ulverston will become a little less special. That’s about it.

It’s altogether different with Sainsburys. They really will provide a bigger range of quality foods at better prices than those available locally, Booths included.

What’s not to like? Well, it’s quite simple – it will rip the heart out of the town centre. And if you support Sainsburys either you deny this or you say it doesn’t matter.

Does it matter? Some insist that if local businesses can’t compete that’s their problem and they deserve to fail. This is a view both harsh and naïve.

It overlooks the fact that there is hardly a level playing field, and, in light of dodgy banks, greedy power companies, and recent spate of tax avoidance schemes, shows an outmoded faith in the market.

And it ignores the knock-on effects. We’re not just talking airy-fairy stuff about healthy environments, quality of life, vibrant communities. A stagnant town centre will have bad consequences for jobs, house prices, schools and safe streets.

Does convenience and saving make up for this? It will certainly be convenient. Why mess about with complicated and expensive Ulverston car parks and then walk around in the rain if you can park easily and for free and get everything under one roof?

But whether the benefits can outweigh the drawbacks is a much harder call.

I don’t really object to Costa and Sainsburys. They’re doing what they supposed to do, pursuing all legal means of making as much money for their shareholders as possible – it’s all about growth, growth and more growth as the Costa boss put it.

It’s not their job to have any interest whatsoever in what happens locally. They’re not supposed to care whether high streets, towns and communities live or die.

So whose job it? Who should care? It’s down to local government to work it out.

What’s desperately needed here is some deep and careful thinking, by intelligent people who take their powers and responsibilities seriously.

It’s not enough to roll over before big business, or to claim that hands are tied, or mumble something about the ‘inevitability’ of ‘progress’.

And – more controversial – it’s not enough simply to please the voters, and ensure re-election.

Suppose most people want Sainsburys. Should we get it? Think about human nature. What most of us most of the time are after is just to get more of what we want. But we confuse what we want with what is good for us, we think mostly just about the short term, and we put little or no weight on what is good for others. If governments simply gave people what they wanted, the world would be very different, but not at all better.

Ulverston is an attractive and lively little town – and the way things are going, and if Sainsburys is kept at bay, it’ll soon be more attractive than Kendal. But it is, I think, a bit fragile, with not a lot in reserve. It could easily be messed up. That mustn’t be allowed to happen.

So let’s hope that this time, at the very least, there’s more than a scuffle.

Environmental philosopher Christopher Belshaw

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:49pm Fri 15 Feb 13

ulverston2025 says...

Hardly an unbiased view - this gentleman has been signed up to oppose Sainsburys for many months now. Let's look at issues for us Ulverstonians, no more travelling to Barrow to supermarket shop, lots of new jobs in Ulverston, significant investment in town. Be real - Ulverston can never compete with Kendal which supports Morrisons, ASDA, Aldi, Booths, Iceland and a large Marks and Spencer food. Shopping in Ulverston is dire at present and it is impossible to shop in town if you work 8 - 5
Hardly an unbiased view - this gentleman has been signed up to oppose Sainsburys for many months now. Let's look at issues for us Ulverstonians, no more travelling to Barrow to supermarket shop, lots of new jobs in Ulverston, significant investment in town. Be real - Ulverston can never compete with Kendal which supports Morrisons, ASDA, Aldi, Booths, Iceland and a large Marks and Spencer food. Shopping in Ulverston is dire at present and it is impossible to shop in town if you work 8 - 5 ulverston2025
  • Score: 0

11:39am Wed 20 Feb 13

soapbox1983 says...

"What’s desperately needed here is some deep and careful thinking, by intelligent people who take their powers and responsibilities seriously."

So because i fully support Sainsburys coming to Ulverston, as an Ulverston resident, it means i lack intelligence, its not about who is cleverer than who, who has more money, a higher standing in society, or a louder voice in an argument!! Its about whats best for Ulverston, its about what the residents, the majority of residents want. Hundreds of people applied for jobs at Costa therefore any intelligent person can see that means there is a market for employment in the town. So the pros of Sainsburys, people will shop at sainsburys in Ulverston instead of in Asda Morrisons or Tesco in Barrow. It means people can save money on fuel and wasted travel time, the entire development from being built to running as a supermarket will create jobs, it will show other businesses that you can get into ulverston and that the people her to support the development of new shops, it gives people a different reason to come to Ulverston, the nearest Sainsburys is Lancaster so it gives people more choice. You people who oppose it would rather see empty shops in Ulverston than businesses accommodating them, get with the times, open your eyes and get with the fact that the economic climate and the way people shop has drastically changed. what worked in the 1920s wouldnt work in todays society. The change from then to now hasnt killed Ulverston has it????
"What’s desperately needed here is some deep and careful thinking, by intelligent people who take their powers and responsibilities seriously." So because i fully support Sainsburys coming to Ulverston, as an Ulverston resident, it means i lack intelligence, its not about who is cleverer than who, who has more money, a higher standing in society, or a louder voice in an argument!! Its about whats best for Ulverston, its about what the residents, the majority of residents want. Hundreds of people applied for jobs at Costa therefore any intelligent person can see that means there is a market for employment in the town. So the pros of Sainsburys, people will shop at sainsburys in Ulverston instead of in Asda Morrisons or Tesco in Barrow. It means people can save money on fuel and wasted travel time, the entire development from being built to running as a supermarket will create jobs, it will show other businesses that you can get into ulverston and that the people her to support the development of new shops, it gives people a different reason to come to Ulverston, the nearest Sainsburys is Lancaster so it gives people more choice. You people who oppose it would rather see empty shops in Ulverston than businesses accommodating them, get with the times, open your eyes and get with the fact that the economic climate and the way people shop has drastically changed. what worked in the 1920s wouldnt work in todays society. The change from then to now hasnt killed Ulverston has it???? soapbox1983
  • Score: 0

11:54am Wed 20 Feb 13

soapbox1983 says...

http://www.gopetitio
n.com/petitions/brin
g-sainsburys-to-ulve
rston.html
http://www.gopetitio n.com/petitions/brin g-sainsburys-to-ulve rston.html soapbox1983
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree